A parent and teenager cooking together in a warm Indiana kitchen during the holidays, a lid and timer within reach of the stove
Lee Boyer: Licensed Agent | AOG Group: Allstate

Lee Boyer

“The most expensive home claims often start with everyday moments—a meal on the stove, a candle on the table, or a space heater on a cold night. Protecting your Indiana home is not just about having insurance after something goes wrong; it is about building safer routines that protect your family, your memories, and the place you count on most.”

November 18, 2026

Cooking, Candles, and Space Heaters: How Indiana Families Can Prevent the Season's Most Expensive Home Claim

Estimated Reading Time:  
14
Minutes

Key takeaways

  • Fire is the rarest common homeowners claim — and by far the most expensive. Triple-I's figures for 2019–2023 put the average fire and lightning claim at $88,170, compared with $15,400 for water damage and freezing.
  • Thanksgiving is the leading day of the year for U.S. home cooking fires. NFPA counted an estimated 1,610 home cooking fires on Thanksgiving Day in 2022, and three and a half times more cooking fires on Thanksgiving than on a typical day across 2018–2022.
  • Holiday fire risk runs in a sequence: cooking fires peak on Thanksgiving, Christmas Eve and Christmas Day; candles and trees peak in December; heating fires peak from December through February.
  • Indiana law splits smoke detector duties. Under Indiana Code 22-11-18-3.5, the owner installs required smoke detectors, and the occupant must test them at least once every six months.

‍

What's in this guide

  1. The biggest home fire risks of the holiday season
  2. Why fire deserves more of your attention than its odds suggest
  3. Thanksgiving and Christmas cooking
  4. Candles, trees and decorations
  5. Space heaters, fireplaces and furnaces
  6. What Indiana law says about smoke detectors
  7. If a fire happens: how homeowners coverage generally responds
  8. A 30-minute holiday home fire safety check
  9. Frequently asked questions

‍

‍

It's Thanksgiving morning. The turkey has been in since eight. There's a pot of potatoes on the front burner, a pan of oil heating for something your aunt insists on frying, two kids underfoot, and a doorbell that hasn't stopped since ten.

‍

You step away to let in the next wave of relatives. It's ninety seconds. Maybe two minutes.

‍

That's usually all it takes. Holiday fires rarely start with anything dramatic. They start with an ordinary pan, an ordinary candle, or an ordinary space heater — and a few minutes when nobody was watching it. This guide walks through holiday home fire safety for Indiana families in the order the risks arrive: the cooking season, the decorating season, and the heating season. Then it covers what your homeowners policy generally does if something goes wrong, and the one Indiana law every household should know.

‍

What are the biggest home fire risks of the holiday season?

The holiday season's home fire risks arrive in three overlapping waves: cooking fires peak on Thanksgiving, Christmas Eve and Christmas Day; candle and Christmas tree fires peak in December; and heating fires peak from December through February.

‍

The National Fire Protection Association's data lays the sequence out clearly:

  • Cooking. Cooking is the leading cause of U.S. home fires and home fire injuries, and the second-leading cause of home fire deaths. Thanksgiving is the single leading day of the year for home cooking fires. In 2022, Christmas Day and Christmas Eve were the second- and third-leading days.
  • Candles and decorations. From 2018 to 2022, U.S. fire departments responded to an average of 835 home fires a year that started with decorations other than Christmas trees. Candles started almost half — 46% — of December decoration fires, compared with about a third across the rest of the year.
  • Christmas trees. NFPA estimates an annual average of 155 home fires started by Christmas trees, causing four civilian deaths, seven injuries and $15 million in direct property damage a year, with electrical equipment involved in more than 40% of them.
  • Heating. From 2019 to 2023, heating equipment was involved in an average of 38,881 home fires a year, with 432 deaths, 1,352 injuries and $1.1 billion in property damage — and those fires peak from December through February.

‍

Put together, it means the eight weeks between Thanksgiving and New Year's stack all three risks on top of each other, in the same homes, during the busiest and most distracted stretch of the year.

‍

Why fire deserves more of your attention than its odds suggest

Here's the uncomfortable arithmetic of fire: it doesn't happen often, but when it does, it costs more than almost anything else a household faces.

‍

Triple-I's figures for homeowners losses from 2019 through 2023 show:

‍

  • Fire and lightning claims occurred at a rate of 0.23 per 100 insured homes a year, with an average claim of $88,170.
  • Water damage and freezing claims were about six and a half times more frequent (1.50 per 100), but averaged $15,400.
  • Wind and hail claims were the most frequent (2.80 per 100), averaging $14,747.

‍

In other words, the average fire claim is roughly six times the average water or wind claim. And the average hides the worst outcomes: a kitchen fire that's put out quickly is a very different event from one that spreads into the walls, the attic, or the rest of the house.

‍

Fire also brings costs that other claims don't: smoke damage throughout the home, weeks or months living somewhere else, and — most importantly — the risk to the people inside. NFPA notes that the vast majority of holiday fires are largely preventable. That's the good news, and it's why a few habits matter more than anything in your policy.

‍

We covered the other big winter risk — frozen pipes, ice dams and roof loads — in our September guide to winter-proofing your Indiana home. Fire is the half of the winter picture that post didn't cover.

‍

Thanksgiving and Christmas cooking: the season's leading fire risk

NFPA is blunt about the cause: unattended cooking is the leading factor in home cooking fires and cooking fire deaths. Holiday cooking makes that worse — more dishes at once, more people in the kitchen, more interruptions, and longer cook times.

‍

The habits that prevent most cooking fires:

  • Stay in the kitchen when anything is on the stovetop. Frying, boiling, grilling and broiling are the high-risk moments. If you have to leave, even briefly, turn the burner off.
  • Use timers for everything in the oven, and check on the turkey or roast regularly rather than trusting it for hours.
  • Keep a lid within reach. If a pan catches fire, sliding a lid over it and turning off the burner smothers it. Never pour water on a grease fire.
  • Keep a "kid-free zone" of about three feet around the stove and anywhere hot food or drinks are being prepared or carried.
  • Keep things that burn away from the stovetop — oven mitts, towels, wooden spoons, food packaging, and loose sleeves.
  • If you fry a turkey, do it outdoors, well away from the house, the garage, the deck and anything overhanging, on a flat surface, with a fully thawed and dried bird. Never in a garage or on a wooden deck.

‍

The mistake people make after a small fire: assuming a stovetop fire that "went out on its own" is over. Grease and smoke can get into range hoods, cabinets and walls. If a fire got past the pan, call the fire department — they'd rather check a fire that's out than arrive at one that isn't.

‍

Candles, trees and decorations

December is when candles and decorations take over from cooking as the fire risk families underestimate.

‍

Candles. That 46% figure is worth sitting with: nearly half of December decoration fires start with candles. The pattern is predictable — a candle on a mantel under a garland, on a table near curtains, or left burning in a room nobody's in.

  • Keep candles at least a foot from anything that can burn, on a sturdy surface, out of reach of kids and pets.
  • Blow them out every time you leave a room or go to bed.
  • Consider flameless LED candles for windows, mantels and anywhere near greenery. They look close to the real thing and remove the risk entirely.

‍

Christmas trees. A real tree dries out as the season goes on, and a dry tree burns fast. Electrical equipment is involved in more than 40% of tree fires, and older NFPA analysis found that in a quarter of tree fires — and most of the deaths — a heat source like a candle or heater was too close to the tree.

  • Water a real tree every day, starting the day it comes home. A tree that stops drinking is a tree that's drying out.
  • Keep the tree at least three feet from any heat source — fireplaces, space heaters, radiators, candles, heat vents and lights that run hot.
  • Check light strings before you hang them. Throw out any with frayed wires, broken sockets or loose connections. Use lights rated for indoor or outdoor use as intended.
  • Turn off tree lights when you go to bed or leave the house. A smart plug or timer makes this automatic.
  • Get rid of the tree after the holidays, before it's bone-dry. Don't store it in the garage or against the house.

‍

Outlets and extension cords. Holiday lighting puts more load on outlets and cords than any other time of year. Don't chain extension cords together, don't run cords under rugs, and don't overload a single outlet.

‍

Space heaters, fireplaces and furnaces

Once the decorations come down, the heating season keeps going. Heating fires peak from December through February, which is why this part of the list lasts longest.

‍

The heater is where the danger concentrates. From 2019 to 2023, space heaters and heating stoves accounted for 29% of home heating fires, but 332 of the 432 heating fire deaths — roughly three of every four. The most common mistake is placement: heaters too close to bedding, curtains, furniture or clothing.

‍

The space heater rules that matter most:

  • Three feet of clearance, every direction. Keep anything that can burn at least three feet from the heater.
  • Plug it directly into a wall outlet — not into an extension cord or a power strip. Space heaters draw a lot of current.
  • Never leave it running in an empty room, when you leave the house, or overnight while you sleep.
  • Use heaters with automatic shut-off if they tip over, and keep them on a hard, level surface — not on a rug or carpet.

‍

Fireplaces and wood stoves. Have chimneys and heating equipment cleaned and inspected annually by a qualified professional. Use a screen, burn only dry, seasoned wood, and put the fire out completely before bed or before leaving home.

‍

Furnaces. Have your furnace inspected before the heavy heating months. Keep the area around it clear — basements and utility rooms tend to become storage, and storage tends to be flammable.

‍

Never use your oven or stovetop to heat your home. Indiana's state safety officials warn that using ovens or stoves as an alternative heating source carries a serious carbon monoxide risk, on top of the fire risk.

‍

What Indiana law says about smoke detectors

Indiana has a specific law on this, and it divides responsibility in a way many people don't realize.

‍

Under Indiana Code 22-11-18-3.5:

  • The owner — or the owner's manager or rental agent — is responsible for installing required smoke detectors.
  • The owner is also responsible for replacing or repairing a required smoke detector within seven working days after receiving written notice that it needs repair or replacement.
  • The occupant is responsible for maintaining the smoke detector and testing it at least once every six months to make sure it works.
  • No one may tamper with or remove a smoke detector except for maintenance.

‍

For homeowners, you're both the owner and the occupant — so all of it is on you. For renters, the landlord installs and repairs; you test and maintain, and you should put any repair request in writing, since the seven-working-day clock starts with written notice.

‍

A practical rhythm: test your detectors in the spring and fall. Daylight saving time ended on November 1 this year, so if you didn't test them when you changed the clocks, this week is a good time. Press the test button on every detector, replace batteries as needed, and replace any detector that's past the manufacturer's recommended life (the date is usually printed on the back).

‍

If a fire happens: how homeowners coverage generally responds

Nothing in this section tells you what your policy covers — that depends on your policy's terms. But it helps to know how a standard homeowners policy is generally organized, because a fire can touch almost every part of it.

  • Dwelling coverage generally helps repair or rebuild the structure of your home after a covered fire.
  • Personal property coverage generally helps replace your belongings — furniture, clothing, electronics, and the gifts under the tree. Whether it pays replacement cost or actual cash value (replacement cost minus depreciation) depends on your policy.
  • Additional living expenses (ALE), sometimes called loss of use, generally help with the extra cost of living elsewhere while your home is repaired. Insurance.com describes standard homeowners policies (HO-2, HO-3, HO-5) as commonly setting this at 20% to 30% of dwelling coverage, and notes it reimburses costs above your normal expenses — a hotel and restaurant meals, for instance, but not the groceries and utilities you'd have paid anyway.
  • Personal liability can come into play if a fire that starts in your home damages a neighbor's property, or if a guest is injured. Holiday hosting brings its own liability questions; we covered those in our guide to protecting your home and guests.

‍

For renters and condo owners, the structure belongs to someone else, but your belongings and your living expenses don't. Insurance.com describes ALE on renters policies (HO-4) as commonly 40% of personal property coverage, and on condo policies (HO-6) as commonly 50%. If you rent, our guide to renters insurance in Indiana explains how inexpensive that protection can be.

‍

The single most useful thing you can do before a fire: a home inventory. After a fire, the hardest part of a personal property claim is remembering and proving what you owned. Walk through every room with your phone recording video — open closets, drawers and cabinets, and narrate as you go. Store the video somewhere that isn't inside the house. It takes under an hour and makes the worst week of your life measurably easier.

‍

For a fuller walkthrough of how Indiana homeowners coverage is structured — limits, deductibles, and how much dwelling coverage is enough — see our complete guide to homeowners insurance in Indiana.

‍

A 30-minute holiday home fire safety check for Indiana families

Do this the weekend before Thanksgiving. It covers all three waves.

‍

1. Test every smoke detector (5 minutes). Press the button on each one. Replace dead batteries and any detector past its replacement date.

‍

2. Check the kitchen setup (5 minutes). Is there a lid for every pan you'll use? A fire extinguisher you can reach — and that you know how to use? Is the stovetop clear of towels, mitts and packaging?

‍

3. Plan the turkey fryer spot (3 minutes, if you fry). Outdoors, flat ground, well away from the house, garage, deck and trees.

‍

4. Inspect holiday lights before hanging (5 minutes). Toss any strand with frayed wires or broken sockets. Set timers or smart plugs so lights turn off overnight.

‍

5. Choose the tree spot (2 minutes). At least three feet from the fireplace, heaters, vents and radiators.

‍

6. Swap candles where you can (2 minutes). LED candles for windows, mantels and near greenery.

‍

7. Check every space heater (5 minutes). Cord in good shape, tip-over shut-off working, three feet of clear space where it'll sit, plugged directly into the wall.

‍

8. Book the chimney or furnace inspection (3 minutes) if it hasn't been done this year.

‍

9. Start the home inventory video — or put it on the calendar for the week after Thanksgiving.

‍

Holiday fire risks at a glance

‍

     Risk | When it peaks | What the data says | The one habit that helps most

‍

Cooking | Thanksgiving, Christmas Eve, Christmas Day | 1,610 home cooking fires on Thanksgiving 2022 (NFPA) | Stay in the kitchen while anything is on the stovetop

Candles | December | 46% of December decoration fires (NFPA, 2018–2022) | Blow out every candle when you leave the room

Christmas trees| December | 155 fires and $15 million damage a year on average (NFPA) | Water daily; keep 3 feet from heat

Space heaters | December–February | 29% of heating fires; 332 of 432 heating deaths (NFPA, 2019–2023) | Three feet of clearance; never overnight

Fireplaces and furnaces | December–February | Part of 38,881 heating fires a year (NFPA, 2019–2023) | Annual professional inspection

Smoke detectors | Year-round | Occupant must test every six months (IC 22-11-18-3.5) | Test when the clocks change

‍

The bottom line

The bottom line is simple: the holiday season stacks the year's biggest fire risks into a few busy weeks, and almost all of them are prevented by habits rather than luck. Stay with the stovetop. Blow out the candle. Water the tree. Give the space heater three feet and turn it off at night. Test the smoke detectors.

‍

Then do the one thing that makes a fire claim manageable if the worst happens: know what your policy says, and have an inventory of what you own.

‍

If you'd like help reviewing your homeowners coverage before the holidays, get a quote or request a personalized policy review from the AOG Group team, or call us at 317-981-2046. You can also read more about how we approach home insurance. From our whole team to yours, have a safe and warm holiday season, Indiana.

‍

Nothing in this article states what any particular policy covers or what any homeowner should purchase. Coverage, limits, availability and eligibility are determined solely by the terms of your own policy, your carrier's underwriting, and applicable Indiana law. Safety guidance is general; follow the manufacturer's instructions for any appliance or heating equipment.

‍

‍

About the author

‍

Lee Boyer is a licensed Property & Casualty and Life & Health insurance agent with more than seven years at Allstate, all of them inside the AOG Group agency in Indiana. He writes about coverage the way he explains it at his desk — in plain English, without the sales pitch.

‍

Sources

Frequently Asked Questions

Does homeowners insurance cover a kitchen fire?

Fire is generally a covered cause of loss under standard homeowners policies, and a kitchen fire can involve dwelling coverage for the structure, personal property coverage for belongings, and additional living expenses if you have to live elsewhere during repairs. What your policy pays, and how much, depends on its terms, limits and deductible. The best way to know is to review your declarations page with your agent before the holidays rather than after a loss.

What day of the year has the most home cooking fires?

Thanksgiving is the leading day of the year for U.S. home cooking fires, according to NFPA. An estimated 1,610 home cooking fires were reported to U.S. fire departments on Thanksgiving Day in 2022, and from 2018 through 2022 Thanksgiving averaged three and a half times more cooking fires than a typical day. Christmas Day and Christmas Eve were the second- and third-leading days in 2022. Unattended cooking is the leading factor.

Is it safe to leave a space heater on overnight?

No. Fire safety officials advise never leaving a space heater running in an unoccupied room, when you leave the house, or while you sleep. Space heaters and heating stoves accounted for 332 of the 432 average annual U.S. home heating fire deaths from 2019 to 2023, per NFPA. Keep heaters at least three feet from anything that can burn, and plug them directly into a wall outlet rather than an extension cord or power strip.

Who is responsible for smoke detectors in an Indiana home?

Under Indiana Code 22-11-18-3.5, the owner — or the owner's manager or rental agent — is responsible for installing required smoke detectors and for repairing or replacing them within seven working days after written notice. The occupant is responsible for maintaining them and testing them at least once every six months. A homeowner who lives in the home is responsible for both.

What is additional living expenses coverage?

Additional living expenses coverage, sometimes called loss of use, generally helps pay the extra cost of living somewhere else while your home is repaired after a covered loss, such as a fire. It typically reimburses costs above your normal expenses — like a hotel or restaurant meals — rather than bills you'd pay anyway. Insurance.com describes it as commonly set at 20% to 30% of dwelling coverage on standard homeowners policies. Your policy's terms determine the actual limit.

Protect Your Future – Get Started Today!

Secure your peace of mind with the right insurance plan. Get a free quote and protect what matters most today!

Get a Quote

Thank you for reaching out

Oops! Something went wrong